Good news stories are difficult enough to come by these days, particularly in Spain, but here's one from Mark Stucklin in Spanish Property Insight.In what was indisputably my worst ever property investment, I bought into a development in Xeresa, near Denia (Valencia) in 2004, being built by a large developer (I expect you know them) specialising in golf resorts. My lawyers were Del Valle Associates in Marbella (so you see I chose pretty well all round). I bought two properties off-plan in 2004, on the basis of a contract which looked OK to me at the time but which I subsequently discovered was seriously flawed. I paid deposits of around 30%. The whole process got off to an extraordinarily slow start, but construction finally began in early 2005, though, according to my builder’s start of works certificate, not officially until November, seven months later. This was very difficult to deal with at the time.
I had by this time parted company with Del Valle and found a new lawyer through your website (Juan Bertomeu of Iuris Consulting). It was soon clear to both of us that if I wanted to get out (which I by then did) it could only be done by claiming on the bank guarantee for non-completion in the required time. Given the force majeure conditions in the contract, we established the earliest date in May 2008 by when the claim could be lodged. It was apparent from my site visits (when we were never allowed actually to enter my own properties!) that they would not be completed by the date we’d defined.
Despite this, I was advised in mid 2008 that the properties had been completed (and that this stage payment and that stage payment were now due). Our claim had not at that time been lodged because my/our view was that every duck had to be in the proverbial row, in terms of documentation, before we did so. We finally lodged the claims on both properties in early September.
These were rejected by the bank because the properties had been “completed”.
To cut a very long story short, we made 12 different submissions to the bank , all of which had to be notarised etc. The bank made an endless succession of what we believed to be wholly unreasonable and non-contractual demands. My view was that however unreasonable the demand we would meet it as quickly as we could, and so we did. One notarised submission we made in November, relating to the unfinished state of the apartments, ran to 25 pages.
Finally, miraculously, the first guarantee was finally paid into my Spanish bank one week before Christmas and the second one week later. I received four years interest on my capital deposit. Additionally, of course, I was repaid in Euros, which were around 30% more valuable on the day I got paid than they were when I’d made my deposit.
In broad terms, therefore, I have in sterling made around 10% per annum on my four year investment (net of legal fees of some 13,000 Euros and my personal costs of 3,000) which, so far as I can see, is tax-free. This is far better than any of the parallel UK investments I made over the same period.
The fact that this profit arose through entirely unintended means does not lessen the feat of genius it represents.
So you see, it can be done!
The lessons (for me at least) are as follows:
Firstly, read the bank guarantee very carefully, on the basis that you might well have to use it. Start with the assumption that they will be extremely reluctant to pay.
Secondly, remember that the developer will seek to give himself more room against his own commitments than he is entitled to, especially at the start of the contract when non-completion is the last thing the buyer is thinking about.
Thirdly, before signing or paying anything, visit the site with your lawyer. Within 5 minutes of my doing so, unfortunately by then well into the contract, my new lawyer, on seeing the proposed layout, told me - accurately as it turned out - why the project would end up years behind schedule due to difficulties in obtaining further permissions not yet sought or agreed.
OK, so it is not a typical investment story, and you'd have to be mad to knowingly attempt to make money in this fashion, but it just goes to show that you should never lose heart. If it can't be done one way, then try another.
A quick verse from Rudyard Kipling to finish:
If you can keep your head when all about you
Are losing theirs and blaming it on you;
If you can trust yourself when all men doubt you,
But make allowance for their doubting too:
If you can wait and not be tired by waiting,
Or, being lied about, don't deal in lies,
Or being hated don't give way to hating,
And yet don't look too good, nor talk too wise.
This could well be a motto for the unprecedented times in which we now live.
______________________
Register now to receive our informative newsletter, save searches and tailor your OverseasCafe.com experience to your own needs.
To view properties in
To View a List of Spanish Agents: Click Here
To View the most Recent News from Spanish Agents: Click Here
To View the Latest Spanish Property News: Click Here
To See a Listing of Upcoming Spanish Exhibitions: Click Here
To See a Selection of Advice on Purchasing in
No comments:
Post a Comment